QUIZ: PHOTOSHOP DISASTER?

Over two hundred of you have sent in the following image and the internet has been a buzz with this particular image. I'd like for you to cast your vote below as to whether or not this is a PSD.

Note: solutions and comments are all welcome but just vote before reading the comments

Update: The image above is actually not a disaster and photo below shows how this shot can be reproduced. You can see the original photo here and the steps to reproduce the pose.